In praise of good Scotch...

[BuckarooBanzai]

Just recently got the all clear to start drinking again...guess what I started with?

Well, if ya don't know, ya didn't read the title of the post!

Seriously, I'm working my way through a fifth of The Balvenie SherryOak 17 as I type this (God bless friends/family who give good booze for Christmas, by the way) and I'm wondering.....

Any other Scotch drinkers out there?

If so, what is your favorite (that you've had) and what is your favorite (that you've only dreamed of, or maybe just sampled a taste of). I guess the real question is, what is your dream bottle (assuming that money and/or availability in your area are not an issue).

Highland, Speyside, Islay...single malt, blended...don't matter a bit. Truth be told, "plain old Dewars" is a damned fine drink, if ya ask me.

Personal opinions are just that and shouldn't be dissed, regardless of what they might be. This thread ain't about bustin' on yer favorites, it is about helping me find a few new faves to sample!

Hell, tell me your favorite bourbon if you prefer! Wild Turkey Rare Breed can give most great Scotch a real run for it's money, if ya ask me. Gentleman Jack ain't no slouch either.

Again, NOT meaning to diss anybody's drink of choice...even if it is Old Grandad or 20 Pipers (and if ya feel the need to slam somebody's favorite, please do it elsewhere).

Just wondering what kinda hard stuff y'all might enjoy sipping. Scotch has been on my "no-no" list for almost a year now, but not any more!

Ya never know who will introduce you to a new favorite, ya know?

So, again, PLEASE no dissing...just tell me what ya dig (and maybe a little about why ya dig it).

I'll start by saying this Balvenie is DAMNED good...but I really prefer Glen Fiddich Solera Reserve (even though it is quite a bit cheaper and often considered crap by "real" Scotch drinkers).

Oh, and as a side note, if ya ever want to really enjoy yer Scotch...quit drinking much for a friggin' year...

[LocoH]

Well said Buck. Myself, I always have a stock of Gentleman Jack, and Johnny Walker Red and Black laying around. For a very fine single malt scotch, I just picked up a bottle of
Johnny Walker King George V Edition.


Its very smooth, i add a splash of sprite and its like

[mycoshepherd]

Laphroaig ("The beautiful hollow by the broad bay") Islay single malt is always my fave tipple. Especially at this time of year. The 15 year is less 'peaty' than the 10 year but both are really smooth.

Bunnahabain as well. Both from Islay. Me and the wife bought a bottle of Glenlivet for my dad last christmas and ended up necking it and that was pretty nice as well. A bit too much bite for my liking - I prefer it a bit smoother - but a nice drink none the less.

[mrpanda]

This is one of my favorites has a really smooth honey like taste,
TheDrinkShop.com : DALWHINNIE - 15 Year Old - Speyside Malt Whisky
And as one of my dream bottles that cost puts out of my reach,
TheDrinkShop.com : DALWHINNIE - 36 Year Old - Highland Malt Whisky
Another really enjoyable bottle was Glenmorangie Cellar 13,
Copenhagen Airport - www.tax-free.dk

[bb4]

i'm a sour mash american whiskey guy myself, but i can definitely tell you what scotch not to drink

SCORESBY SCOTCH

Scorsebey's Scotch - ack - taste like tequila....
got a bottle from an employee, i know it's the thought that counts but damn this stuff is something else...

[CoyoteMesc]

After a long summer day; Or days so cold the penguins would rather be indoors a good drink can remove the edge and give me a natural high, sense of well being and 'at peace'. Once that first drink goes down the grill in my yard looks so inviting. The warmth and comfort of home and friends tell me how lucky I am to be alive. I Love Bourbon.

Four Roses has to be one of the smoothest bourbons I have been fortunate enough to have in my chest. That winter sip goes down like a warm cup of bourbon flavored coffee, even if it has been chilled.

Here's to good drinks

[Fresh Brewed]

More of a high end beer kinda guy, but I gave a gift of 15 year old glinlivit for Christmas, and I was told that it is very good.

[stoney]

johnny walker black label & crown royal special reserve are my two favorites

[HaiLeY]

Don't like scotch much, but looove burbon. Got a Bottle of Gentleman Jack and Maker's Mark for Xmas presents and the Maker's Mark was superior by far imo, although both were very nice...

[lionelfire]

I like glenlivet, Bookers is the smoothest bourbon i've tasted, but a bit expensive for me

[Hippie3]

Originally Posted by HaiLeY

Don't like scotch much, but looove burbon. Got a Bottle of Gentleman Jack and Maker's Mark for Xmas presents and the Maker's Mark was superior by far imo, although both were very nice...

the Mark is decent but knob creek's a wee bit better, imo.

[AmBe]

for scotch i mainly buy macallan 12, i recently bought a bottle of tullibardine and liked it alot.

for bourbon i like woodford reserve.

[witchdr11]

I like my Blue label mixxed with coke, a cherry and a little umbrella!


JUST KIDDING

[AmBe]

thanks for posting this thread.

stopped at the liquor store on the way home from work and was looking for a scotch (one of them days). remembered this thread when i saw The Balvenie, went for the cheaper 10 year and was pleasantly surprised.

on my 3rd drink now and loving it. will try the 12 year next